Curator’s statement
The Fifth Avenue Hotel is a design hotel in the truest sense: bold, layered, romantic, and entirely self-assured. I have stayed here twice now, and both times I have still found myself in awe of just how beautiful it is. With interiors by Martin Brudnizki, every corner feels deeply considered, from the fabric-lined walls to the jewel-toned rooms and the little tucked-away nooks that make the hotel feel personal rather than simply polished. This is not an everyday hotel. It is a special-occasion hotel, the kind of place I would choose for an anniversary, milestone birthday, or celebration that deserves to feel memorable. Portrait Bar sets the mood perfectly: intimate, elegant, and ideal for a romantic pre-dinner drink or a celebratory nightcap. What makes the hotel truly stand out, though, is the service. The staff knows your name, makes you feel genuinely welcome, and reminds you that friendly, personal hospitality is a lost art. There is no gym, and the location is not my usual downtown preference, but I would make the trip any day for a hotel this special.
The Fora Difference
Book with Martha Aimée McInnis to access exclusive perks and experiences on your trip.
Killer perks
Free upgrades, spa credits and more—we got you
Personalized recs
Customized travel planning for your style
Insider knowledge
Expert advice from people who’ve actually been there
Where to stay in New York
Unlock perks by contacting Martha Aimée McInnis to book your trip.
The Fifth Avenue Hotel is one of those rare hotels that feels even more beautiful in person than it does in photos. I have stayed here twice, and both times I still found myself stopping to take in the details: the colors, the textures, the lighting, the art, the way every room seems to have its own mood. It is bold and layered without feeling chaotic, and glamorous without feeling cold. With interiors by Martin Brudnizki, every corner feels deeply curated, from the fabric-lined walls to the soulful little nooks that give the property so much character. It feels like a hotel with a point of view, and that is what makes it memorable.
To me, this is a true special-occasion hotel. It is the place I would recommend for an anniversary, a milestone birthday, a romantic weekend, or any celebration where you want the hotel itself to be part of the experience. It has that sense of occasion from the moment you arrive. It is not necessarily where I would send someone looking for a casual crash pad or a practical business stay. It is for someone who appreciates design, atmosphere, and the feeling of being somewhere a little extraordinary.
Portrait Bar deserves its own mention because it extends the hotel’s vibe in the most perfect way. It is cozy, elegant, and romantic, with a room that feels meant to be settled into rather than rushed through. This is exactly where I would go for a pre-dinner drink, a quiet celebration, or a nightcap that turns into one more conversation. I would not choose it for a wild girls’ night or a loud evening with the boys. The couches here are meant to be sunken into and savored.
The service is what truly sets the hotel apart. The staff knows your name, remembers small details, and makes you feel genuinely welcome without ever being over the top. Friendly, personal service can feel like a lost art, and The Fifth Avenue Hotel gets it right. There is no gym, and as a downtown girl the location is not my usual choice, but honestly, I would make the trip any day for a hotel this special. It is stunning, warm, deeply personal, and the kind of place that stays with you after you leave.
Need to know
For more travel inspiration and insider recommendations, check out our New York City page.
Travel Advisor
Martha Aimée McInnis
Martha Aimée McInnis
Get in touch with Martha Aimée McInnis
Did you like this guide? Reach out to customize and book your own experience. Or, just to chat about travel in general.