Things to Do in Eleuthera, Bahamas curated by Brian Lonergan | Fora Travel

Things to Do in Eleuthera, Bahamas

Advisor - Brian Lonergan

Curated By

Brian Lonergan

Icon Share

SHARE

  • Beach

  • Adventure

  • Outdoors

  • Food

White sand beach with cabanas In Harbor Island, Bahamas.

Curator’s statement

My love for The Bahamas, particularly Eleuthera, is personal – the house where my maternal grandfather was born, on Pine Street in Governor’s Harbour, still stands, and I grew up visiting Nassau and Eleuthera (when you could still travel there with just a birth certificate). I proposed to my wife on family land in Eleuthera and can’t wait to show the kids this part of their ancestry. While you can certainly stay in style (think: the pink-sand resorts of Harbour Island), the greatest luxury lies in having that postcard-picture beach to yourself (yes, this still is possible here!).

The Fora Difference

Book with Brian to access exclusive perks and experiences on your trip.

Find Fora Travel on Instagram

Killer perks

Free upgrades, spa credits and more—we got you

Find Fora Travel on Instagram

Personalized recs

Customized travel planning for your style

Find Fora Travel on Instagram

Insider knowledge

Expert advice from people who’ve actually been there

Where to stay

Icon 

Unlock these perks by contacting Brian to book your trip.

Things to do

Man snorkeling in shallow blue water.

In contrast to the well charted capital of Nassau, Eleuthera and other “out islands” can often feel like the land that time forgot. 

Firstly: beg, borrow or steal a copy of The Elusive Beaches of Eleuthera. Second, book your rental car through one of the many local residents that do so out of Governor’s Harbour airport (tell Stanton or Butch we say hello!).  Third: find your freedom. 

The name “Eleuthera” comes from the Greek word for “freedom,” and while the original shipwrecked settlers were seeking religious liberty, today’s traveler is more apt to seek freedom from screens, Zooms, and to-dos of all kinds.  This is a place where time slows down; three days feels like a week, a week like a month. 

Of all the gorgeous beaches that Eleuthera has to offer, Lighthouse Beach is a hidden gem you’re going to want to see. I will warn you though, the journey is not for everyone, and that’s part of Lighthouse Beach’s appeal. To get there, you must travel along a long, dirt road, lined with unforgiving potholes. It’s located in South Eleuthera, at the southernmost tip of the island. Its pink sand and stunning, clear blue water will be sure to have you in awe. Be sure to bring snorkeling gear and some snacks.

In North Eleuthera, check out the Sapphire Blue Hole. Eleuthera is home to many sinkholes, but the Sapphire Blue Hole is the most acclaimed. Said to have healing powers, take a swim in the seemingly bottomless geological phenomenon. If you’re in South Eleuthera, Ocean Hole at Rock Sound is another impressive sinkhole worth checking out.

Eleuthera is among the world’s top bonefishing destinations, and your hotel can help match you with a local guide based on your experience level.  Speaking of guides, with an experienced one you’ll also want to swim, snorkel or dive the Current Cut, about two thirds of a mile long, and one of the world’s fastest drift dives.

Advisor - Brian Lonergan

A note from Brian

The "island called Freedom" is 110 miles long, barely one mile wide, and the highest elevation (at Glass Window Bridge in Gregory Town) is 200 feet above sea level. It's essentially a giant sand bar with world-class beaches that are relatively unknown. Check out the natural pools called Queen’s Bath nearby for a refreshing dip.

Places to eat & drink

Man holding a coconut with a paper straw inside of it.

Tippy’s: Part of Pineapple Fields hotel, the beachside Tippy’s has been a mainstay on Banks Road for nearly two decades. 

Cocodimama: Eleuthera is not much for white tablecloths – this is about as formal as it gets, which is still very relaxed, beachfront dining. 

Local homes: Part of the fun of Eleuthera is driving the main road (yes there is one) and spotting “lunch” signs in driveways. That means you can pull in, knock on the back or side door and find out what the owner is cooking today: fried chicken, peas and rice, mac and cheese, coleslaw, and more.

Need to Know

Pack easy slip-on / off shoes - you’ll be removing them much more than you’re used to. 

Don’t tip (except if you have a private guide).  And if you do, don’t pass cash hand to hand. Present it in an envelope held with two hands and a bow of approximately 30 degrees.  Voila

These are just a couple of the tips I offer in my pre-travel etiquette guide.  Ask me for more!

Advisor - Brian Lonergan

Advisor

Brian Lonergan

Get in touch with Brian

Reach out to customize and book your own experience. Or, just to chat about travel in general.